[sacw] SACW | 18 Jan. 03
Harsh Kapoor
aiindex@mnet.fr
Sat, 18 Jan 2003 03:56:29 +0100
South Asia Citizens Wire | 18 January 2003
__________________________
#1. Asians in Britain: 400 Years of History (Rozina Visram)
#2. South Asia: Sagarmatha Declaration and Programme of Action (Kathmandu)
#3. The Scandalous ways of the Indian State: Imprisonment and release
of Iftikhar Gilani
- Rousing welcome for Gilani
-Gilani calls for debate on OSA
- Notes from prison (Iftikhar Gilani)
#4. India: The enemy within (Saba Naqvi)
#5. India: Communal Riots 2002 (Asghar Ali Engineer)
#6. India: Alienating minorities Putting Hindutva in place (Editorial
, The Statesman)
#7. In the name of the Lord : A sordid mixture of crime and moral
decay covers the face of mystic India
(Ajay Uprety/Chitrakoot Kanhaiah Bhelari)
#8. Hindutva at Work: Stories - India, US, UK
#9. Low caste leader's high-cost party (Edward Luce)
__________________________
#1.
ASIANS IN BRITAIN: 400 Years of History
Rozina Visram
2002/04 / 504pp
ISBN: 0745313736
Pluto Press
345 Archway Road
London N6 5AA
U.K.
http://www.plutobooks.com/
'A lively - and timely - survey of British Indian history.' Salman
Rushdie / 'Rozina Visram's excellent book does a great deal to
explain how the idea of white supremacy lingers.' Hanif Kureishi, The
Observer / 'Painstakingly researched, scholarly, succinct and
gripping to read.' Dilip Hiro, TLS / 'A compelling book ... should be
essential reading.' Farrukh Dhondy, The Guardian / This is a classic
account of Indians in Britain and draws on Visram's earlier and much
lauded study, Ayahs, Lascars and Princes. Spanning three centuries,
it tells the history of the Indian community in Britain, from the
indentured servants of the seventeenth century to the princes,
professionals, students, conscript soldiers and refugees of the
twentieth century. Drawing on recently declassified government
documents, Visram examines the nature of Asian migration; official
attitudes towards the immigrant community; the reactions and
perceptions of the British people; and the social, cultural and
political lives of the Asians themselves. This new edition of
Visram's earlier study has been thoroughly revised, significantly
expanded and completely updated. It remains an invaluable
contribution to our understanding of the origins of the multicultural
communities that play such an important part in Britain today.
Rozina Visram is an independent scholar working on multiculturalism
and education.
______
#2.
SAGARMATHA DECLARATION AND PROGRAMME OF ACTION
Adopted at the International Consultation on Water Resource Development in
South Asia and the Report of the World Commission on Dams 8-10 December 2002,
Kathmandu, Nepal
We, the participants from the countries of South Asia, namely, Nepal, India,
Pakistan, Bhutan and Sri Lanka have gathered together with our allies and
friends in Kathmandu, Nepal to review water resource policies and projects
relating to water and hydropower, to assert the inalienable rights of the
people of South Asia over the resources of our lands, and to ensure
people-centered development as well as justice and peace among all
communities and people in South Asia. [...]
http://www.mnet.fr/aiindex/2002/EngineerJan03.html
______
#3.
Press Club of India, Delhi Union of Journalists and Indian Women
Press Corps organised a meeting on January 17, at 4.30pm at the
Press Club of India, Raisina Road to felicitate Iftikhar Gilani.
See report:
The Hindustan Times, January 18, 2003
Rousing welcome for Gilani
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/printedition/180103/detCIT12.shtml
o o o
The Hindu
Saturday, Jan 18, 2003
Gilani calls for debate on OSA
By Our Special Correspondent
NEW DELHI JAN. 17. The Kashmir Times journalist, Ifthikar Gilani,
today called for a debate on the Official Secrets Act, sections of
which were contrary to the provisions of the Freedom of Information
Act passed by Parliament recently. He said that a debate on the OSA,
an act created in 1923 by a colonial regime, would be the ``greatest
compensation'' for the seven months he spent in jail.
Mr. Gilani said he believed that it was because he was a journalist
that his case got so much attention leading to its withdrawal. There
were, however, tens of people languishing in jail for offences under
the OSA, many of whom like him had committed no crime.
Mr. Gilani's lawyer, V. K. Ohri, drew attention to the fact that
while there had been just 60 cases filed under the OSA in 25 years,
in a fraction of that time, one police department - Delhi Police's
Special Cell - had filed seven cases under the Act. Mr. Ohri said
that the OSA was an anachronism and should be amended keeping in view
the access to information that technological advances allowed.
Mr. Gilani also called on the press not to play into the hands of an
establishment which thrived on mis-reporting. The coverage of the
early weeks of his case, he said were ``a lesson to all journalists,
particularly my younger colleagues'', on how not to report.
Describing the 18-hour-long Income-Tax raid on his home, during which
he was locked inside a room for hours, he said he was amazed to find
television channels reporting variously that he was absconding or
that his wife was absconding. After he was formally charged,
newspapers reported that he had confessed to being an ISI agent,
while what he had told the court - that the charges were frivolous
and that the so-called secret document was published - were never
recorded.
o o o
The Hindustan Times, 18 January 2003
Notes from prison
Iftikhar Gilani
http://www.hindustantimes.com/news/printedition/180103/detIDE01.shtml
______
#4.
Al-Ahram Weekly
16 - 22 January 2003
Issue No. 621
The enemy within
Hindu nationalists have formulated a new ideological platform centred
around fighting terrorism that could spell disaster for India's
Muslim community, reports Saba Naqvi from New Delhi
PHOTO caption : Indian soldiers roll out Pritivi missiles during a
full dress rehersal for the 15 January Army Day
The Hindu nationalist Bharitiya Janat Party (BJP), which leads
India's coalition government, has a new found ideology to fight a
series of state elections in 2003, before national polls slated for
October 2004. The party's top strategists now say fighting terrorism
is, "our new ideological plank". On the face of it, this is no
different from the resolve of several nations across the world. But
in the Indian context it has worrying implications, particularly for
the country's 140 million Muslims.
The landslide victory of the BJP in Gujarat last month came after a
series of humiliating reverses in election contests in crucial states
like Uttar Pradesh and Punjab. The party managed to retain power in
Gujarat by running a campaign more vicious than any seen in India
before. The controversial chief minister, Narendra Modi, openly
targeted the state's Muslims in his speeches and public rallies. His
message was crude and simple. Terrorism equals Muslims. Muslims equal
terrorism. He effectively manipulated emotions in the aftermath of 11
September to magnify incidents like the burning of a train in
Gujarat, that claimed the lives of over 50 Hindu pilgrims and a
terrorist attack on a Hindu temple in the state capital, to demonise
an entire community.
Mass hysteria often turns the truth on its head. In the Gujarat riots
in February and March 2002, triggered by the train attack, the
minority Muslim community bore the brunt of the violence. At least
2,000 were killed, women were brutally raped and babies burned alive.
Civil society groups are still calculating the other costs of the
worst ever pogrom in independent India: 300 Sufi shrines demolished,
entire neighbourhoods incinerated, and the economic might of the
Muslim community completely destroyed. Yet, barely 10 months on, the
BJP and its allies managed to run a remarkable election campaign
where the electorate were told that Muslims, just 10 per cent of
Gujarat's population, are a threat to the security of the Hindu
majority.
Chief Minister Modi has made a fine art of exploiting the fear of the
unknown terrorist. Terrorism, in his vocabulary, does not come from
Pakistan alone. The enemy, he repeatedly implied, lies within. Indian
Muslims equal Pakistanis equal terrorists. Gujarat, with its long
history of communal clashes, has long been viewed as a laboratory of
the Hindu right. It is a border state and in no other part of the
country has the BJP repeatedly won elections with such huge
majorities. Even BJP ideologues doubt whether the "Gujarat-line" can
be transplanted to other states. But this will not stop them from
trying. Essentially, this means that continued "low-level" terrorism
actually suits the BJP's domestic agenda. Some months ago the
national press tore apart the government version of a so- called
strike by two terrorists in a Delhi shopping mall, alleging that it
was stage-managed.
The BJP exploded on the national scene just over a decade ago, when
it called for the demolition of a mosque in the northern Indian town
of Ayodhya, allegedly built over the ruins of a temple marking the
birthplace of the Hindu god, Ram. Since then the party's ideology has
been defined by three major demands: The construction of a temple on
the site of the demolished mosque; abolition of a separate personal
law for the Muslim community; and abolition of Article 370 of the
Indian constitution which gives special status to Kashmir and
prevents Indians from buying land there. Indeed, extremists of the
Hindu right argue that the problem of Muslim majority Kashmir would
be solved overnight if India would follow Israel's example and set up
settlements in the troubled state.
Even though the party has been at the head of a national coalition
since 1998 it has not been able to deliver on any of these demands.
Instead, it has had to drop them to forge alliances with smaller
parties. While the temple dispute is now under the purview of the
courts, there is no hope of ever changing the laws governing Muslims
or Kashmir. To do so would require constitutional amendments, only
possible if the BJP were to win large majorities in both houses of
parliament. This is becoming increasingly difficult in an era of
coalitions where regional-based parties increasingly hold the balance
of power in their hands.
Post-Gujarat, the BJP modified its ideological position, saying the
fight against terrorism is even more important than building the
temple. Most countries view terrorism as a security problem. India
too has been fighting terrorism for years in Punjab, Kashmir and the
North-Eastern states. That said, this is the first time terrorism has
been turned into an ideological platform by a cadre-based party.
Sociologist Dipankar Gupta has analysed the BJP's success in
generating hysteria over terrorism. "This illustrates that the fears
of a collapse of the Indian state are very strong. After all, our
country is defined by Partition and the creation of Muslim Pakistan.
The West sees terrorism as a security or law and order problem. But
with our history the issue of sovereignty gets involved."
It is no coincidence that many luminaries from the Hindu right are
refugees from Pakistan. They see no reason why India should give
special rights to a community they hold responsible for historical
injustices. They openly complain of the country's "pampering of
Muslims".
Narendra Modi is representative of this new breed, which has no use
for secular rhetoric. Modi arrived in Delhi last week to hold his
first press conference in the nation's capital since his victory last
month. He began by telling the national press, largely opposed to
him, that "you've all had the mickey taken out of you." He refused to
offer any apologies for the horrific violence his state has witnessed
or give any assurance guaranteeing the security of its Muslims.
Described as "the hero of hatred" he was triumphant and unrepentant.
A scribe commented that even Hitler had been elected democratically.
In 1947, when India attained Independence from British rule in the
midst of horrific Hindu-Muslim bloodletting, Jawaharlal Nehru and
Mahatma Gandhi expended most of their energy rushing to Muslim
localities to assure the community that they would be safe in secular
India. Narendra Modi is the latest and most vicious in the line of
BJP leaders who are undermining the great ideas that governed the
creation of this vast nation.
______
#5.
[January 17, 2003]
India: Communal Riots 2002
by Asghar Ali Engineer
India could not free itself of curse of communalism even more than
fifty years after independence. If anything it has been getting worse
year after year. There has been not a single year in
post-independence period, which has been free of communal violence
though number of incidents may vary. The year 2002 has been one of
the worst years in this matter [...]
{ READ FULL TEXT AT : http://www.mnet.fr/aiindex/2002/EngineerJan03.html }
______
#6.
The Statesman (Caluctta)
January 18,2003
Editorial
Alienating minorities Putting Hindutva in place
Buoyed by his win at the hustings, Narendra Modi now seeks to
implement the manifesto on which he managed to come to power -
Hindutva. To him it means putting minorities in their place. He is
already planning a Bill to ban "forced" conversions and look into
reforming madrasas. Judging by the past record of dealing with
minorities both steps are worrying. Christians in Gujarat have faced
the largest number of attacks on churches, priests and nuns by the
VHP lumpen in the last few years than anywhere else in the country -
all ostensibly to discourage conversions. Proof of the "force"
alleged is never provided. The Bill will ensure that harassment of
Christians will no longer be surreptitious under the VHP banner; it
will happen openly by enforcers of the law. Modi's police will
complete what the VHP started. Modi cites similar legislation in
Madhya Pradesh, Orissa and Tamil Nadu as precedents but these have
not been a cause for worry; in the Gujarat laboratory the story will
be different.
As for the plight of Gujarat's other minority, the wounds inflicted
during the pogrom last year still hurt. Effects of the worst communal
carnage in post-independent India are still visible. Minorities feel
helpless and dejected, outcasts in a system where they can expect no
justice. Every day so-called "sporadic" incidents are reported where
houses or business are set on fire and people killed or injured. The
incidents have become commonplace are hardly noticed. Easy targets
are mosques and dargahs. The 150-year-old Giban Shah Pir Dargah and
the dargah of the Sufi saint Imam Shah in Pirana were both scenes of
violence recently. The majority of devotees at both dargahs are
Hindus as are the trustees. Ironically they epitomise the communal
harmony that prevailed in Gujarat before the VHP began to change
things. In order to try and wean Hindu devotees away, they are being
told by the Hindutva brigade that these pirs or saints were
foreigners and should not be revered. They were venerated for
generations because of their good deeds among the community in which
they lived. But overnight they have become foreigners. Whatever
little interaction there is left between the majority and minorities
in Gujarat is being threatened. Does anybody care?
______
#7.
The Week
Jan 19, 2003
CoverStory/Investigation
In the name of the Lord
A sordid mixture of crime and moral decay covers the face of mystic India
By Ajay Uprety/Chitrakoot & Ayodhya and
Kanhaiah Bhelari/Varanasi & Gaya
Talk about karma. Divyanand Maharaj believes in here and now, rather
than in kingdom come. The spiritual head of Swargashram Pilikothi,
who lords over a 1,000-acre agricultural and commercial estate in
Chitrakoot and more than 250 ashrams worth Rs 100 crore in different
places of India, has hired private security guards to protect his
life and property. "There are people who have an eye on the land,"
says the mahant who has an ever-present ring of gun-toting men around
him. "They only understand the language of the gun."
"There are people who have an eye on the land,"
says Divyanand Maharaj (left) of Chitrakoot.
Chitrakoot, Madhya Pradesh
Famous as: The place of Lord Ram's 14-year exile
Infamous for: Gun culture, land grab; 2,000 gun licences issued in two years
Guns speak louder than words in Chitrakoot, where Lord Ram lived in
exile. Prime property in this Madhya Pradesh town, on the border of
Uttar Pradesh, costs Rs 30 lakh a bigha (8,000 sq. feet), much more
than in big cities in the state. Some 30 lakh pilgrims visit the 500
temples and mutts here every year, filling their coffers with liberal
offerings. To safeguard their temporal powers, many sanyasis and
priests carry firearms; the district administration has issued more
than 2,000 gun licences in the last two years alone.
Shooting swamis (not flying ones), muscle power (not mind power) and
market logic (not maya)-these are the new traits of mystic India. In
Ayodhya, the birthplace of Lord Ram in Uttar Pradesh, where there are
no fewer than 8,000 mutts, 109 swamis stand accused of crimes ranging
from gun-running to murder. Sadhus in Amarkantak in Madhya Pradesh
are engaged in holy wars with one rival sect or the other to grab
land.
It is in the name of God that Anoopdas Maharaj, mahant of Khaki
Akhara in Chitrakoot, carries a revolver and bullets round his waist.
"What's wrong, even Parasuram carried arms," he says, referring to
the Brahmin sage who avenged his father's slayers.
Puroshottam Narain Sharan, a doctor-turned-sadhu who has been in
Chitrakoot since 1978, says he would have no compunction in taking up
arms. "You have to protect your house from someone who enters it. It
is the same with ashrams," he says. "It is better that you protect it
than turn to the police."
The battle of sanyasis in Ayodhya caught national attention on May
29, 2001, with the attack on mahant Nritya Gopal Das, the deputy
chief of Ram Janmabhoomi Nyas, a trust for building the controversial
Ram temple. Das had apparently played an active role in removing
Devramdas Vedanti as mahant of the prestigious Ramvallabha Kunj
temple and enthroning Ram Shanker.
In 1998, saffron-clad sadhus opened fire on the residents of Guptar
Ghat, 10 km from Ayodhya, killing four. The sadhus, said to be the
disciples of Mohan Das alias Mauni Baba, mahant of Yagya Shala
Ashram, did it to scare local people away to grab land. In another
gruesome incident 10 years ago, the 70-year-old mahant of Jankighat
temple was strangled by three sadhus to gain control of the temple
whose property was worth Rs 15 crore.
Criminal swamis became a problem in Ayodhya three decades ago when
lawbreakers from Bihar and eastern Uttar Pradesh started taking
shelter in temples there to escape the police. One of them, Kamdev
Singh, died in a shootout with the police.
One for the soul: Swamis in Ayodhya sharing a bottle of rum
Ayodhya, Uttar Pradesh
Famous as: Birthplace of Ram
Infamous for: Gun culture, land grab-109 swamis face criminal
charges; 40% of 6,000 temples involved in land or power dispute
The bloody clashes became common when Ram Kripal Das from Munger in
Bihar took refuge in Ayodhya in the 80s after killing a politician.
He virtually ruled over Ayodhya for a decade till his own accomplices
killed him. He had two dozen cases against him, including the murder
of Mahanand Jha, head of Sanatan temple. Harbhajan Das, mahant of
Hanuman Garhi, who sneaked into Ayodhya in the 60s, had links with
dacoits of Chambal. He, too, fell to the guns of his accomplices in
1984.
"Mutts of Ayodhya have become a safe haven for criminals," admits
Gyan Das, the mahant of Sagaria Patti. Capturing a temple fetches a
lot of money and power, and it is done by influential mahants of the
city. In April 1999, alleges Kripal Das, mahant of Bhakt Mal Bhavan,
an influential mahant in Ayodhya incited a mob to capture his land. A
case in this connection is on in the district court of Faizabad.
About 40 per cent of the 6,000 temples in the city are involved in
disputes regarding land or seat of power. For instance, the dispute
about the 128-year-old Lakshman Quila temple built by the raja of
Rewa, Raghu Raj Singh, revolved round the seat of the mahant. Three
years ago, Maithali Shankaracharya, one of the claimants, was hurt in
a bomb attack allegedly at the behest of his rival, Sanjay Jha alias
Maithali Ram Sharan. The dispute was sorted out following the
intervention of the chief minister.
"The police remain spectators because of the immense political
connections of the sadhus," says a senior police officer. Four years
ago, the Ayodhya police tried to identify the criminal sadhus but
politicians thwarted the attempt. It is difficult to trace criminals
in ashrams because every sanyasi sheds his past identity and takes a
new name.
ODE TO MORTALITY: The Ganga is dying of pollution from burnt bodies and wastes
Politicians use the mutts and mahants to widen their support base by
splitting the sadhus and devotees. One of the fights is over
Amarkantak, which sits atop the Maikal ranges from which the Narmada
originates. Amarkantak remained a part of Madhya Pradesh when the
state was bifurcated in November 2000, but Chattisgarh Assembly
Speaker Rajendra Prasad Shukla, who hails from the region, will not
let it be. In the fight for the Jaleswar temple complex, he has
allegedly pitted Mahant Naresh Giri against Mahant Kamal Giri, who
has the support of the Madhya Pradesh government. Land grabbing is a
mantra for many sadhus in Amarkantak's 40 ashrams, of which only
seven are registered under the Madhya Pradesh Societies Registration
Act. Last year, Swami Sukdevananda, who has a palatial ashram and
temple, allegedly asked his men to shoot Swami Prakashananda
following a property dispute. Prakashananda took the bullets in his
arm, but died a few months later. Sukdevananda has fled the scene.
Crime in Gaya, unlike in other parts of Bihar, is under control. The
holy city where Gautama Buddha attained enlightenment, however, is
often tense with fights between Hindu and Buddhist priests for
supremacy. "Even the deities of the two religions must be ashamed of
the behaviour of their devotees," says a local leader.
At times, the fight among sadhus can be over something as trivial as
sharing water from a tap. Once, a sadhu in Amarkantak had a scuffle
with a truck driver who did not give way. Without batting an eyelid,
he whipped out his gun and shot at the tyres of the truck, leaving
the driver shell-shocked.
Pilgrims are too numb to react to the volley of questions that greets
them at Pehowa, where the Pandavas performed obsequies for the 18
lakh soldiers who died in the epic battlefield in Kurukshetra, in
Haryana. The Pandavas got peace, but today pilgrims who come for
post-cremation rituals get fleeced.
A few inquiries, and the rituals begin. The items for puja-coconuts,
fruits, cloth, lamps, ghee-all come from a little sack for which the
person pays with just a raised eyebrow. The puja over, all the
materials go back to the sack till the next mourner pays for them.
And when it comes to the offerings, you have to shell out almost five
times the amount you initially had in mind.
Paying for your sins: At Pehowa pilgrims have to meet priests'
exorbitant demands
Pehowa, Haryana
Famous as: Place where the Pandavas performed obsequies for those
killed in Kurukshetra
Infamous for: People who come for post-cremation rituals get fleeced
For the priest it is a means to sustain tradition! "It is difficult
to get our children to do this," says a priest. "If these traditions
have to live on, the offering must be enough for them to live on."
But in the name of ritual, the priest demands everything a person
requires for six months, a year, five years or ten-whatever he can
squeeze out of the mourner. The list includes cash, cot, mattress,
quilts, bedsheets, pillows, food and even things like a torch or
hurricane lantern, a walking-stick, clothes, utensils or a hand fan,
if not an electric one! These too, are kept ready and all that a
mourner has to do is pay the cost. They are then ready to be recycled.
In August, Maharashtra Minister of State Digambar Bagal bore the
brunt of arrogance and exploitation of priests at the temple town of
Pandharpur. Fresh after his induction as minister, Bagal went to pay
obeisance to Lord Vithoba, one of the most revered deities in
Maharashtra. After the puja, the priest, Balasaheb Ramchandra Badve,
demanded Rs 500 in addition to what Bagal had offered. The priest was
arrested under the Temples Act, 1980, and later released on bail, but
exploitation of devotees has hardly stopped.
"Pay the Badves (priests) and they will ensure that you get a long
enough darshan," says an official of the temple trust. There have
been cases of the priests actually taking back the prasad when
devotees failed to pay the amount they demanded.
To break the stranglehold of the priests, the trust allowed a
separate darshan for those who donated Rs 100 or more. The decision
was implemented on November 22, with the district collector becoming
the first donor, but the trust annulled it on December 28. By then,
more than Rs 3 lakh had been added to the coffers.
In temple towns of Tirupati, Palani and Puri it is trade of a
different kind-flesh. A study commissioned by the National Commission
for Women a few years ago, on the status of widows in religious
places, noted that the flesh trade was flourishing in Vrindavan and
Mathura with the full knowledge of the police, administration, holy
men and politicians. There are 3,500 widows in Vrindavan and Mathura,
according to the human resource development ministry.
Pandharpur, Maharashtra
Famous as: Temple of Lord Vithoba, one of the most revered deities in
Maharashtra
Infamous for: Exploitation by priests
The plight of the widows of Varanasi-the plot of Deepa Mehta's Water,
which invited protests from Hindu zealots-are deplorable. Shunned by
their families and society, they live in shelters waiting for death
to liberate them. Most of the women are too old to work, but still do
as domestic helps to survive. Others beg on the steps leading to the
river. They remember having filled up forms to receive widow pension
from the government (Rs 400 a month), but no money has reached them.
The young widows are exploited by organised crime syndicates, with
the blessings of corrupt officials and politicians. In 1998, on the
complaint of a girl, the police raided a house at Sejopuri locality
and arrested a few people. The girls told the police that they were
being supplied to a number of influential leaders and officials. The
CBI is probing the case.
A meeting in 2001 of the National Human Rights Commission and the
department of women and child development, and governments of Uttar
Pradesh and West Bengal (from where most widows come), highlighted
the need to carry out rehabilitation programmes.
TEMPORAL POWER: A sadhu in Bihar with private security guards
Gaya, Bihar
Famous as: Place of Gautama Buddha's enlightenment
Infamous for: Fight between Buddhist monks and swamis for power
D. Ramakrishna, who tries to rehabilitate sex workers through his
NGO, Rural Institute for Social Education in Tirupati, says that
age-old systems like Devadasis, Joginis and Mathammas had given
religious sanction to prostitution. When the government banned these,
survival of these temple courtesans became an issue, and prostitution
seemed to be the only way out. But the sex workers do not have to
work in the railway stations or streets anymore in Tirupati. With an
inflow of 65,000 visitors daily and more than a lakh on special
occasions, customers seek them out.
Prostitution and crime around temples may seem incongruous, but
paradoxes are what hold fascination for the foreign tourist. It is
not uncommon to see a foreigner watching the 'spectacle' of a
cremation at Varanasi on the banks of the Ganga where mortality and
immortality, as Gita Mehta writes in Karma Cola, are laid out in
perfect sequence. The Ganga itself is dying of pollution, thanks to
religious tourism. Travellers throw garlands and ash covered in
plastic bags into the river already polluted by half-burnt corpses
and industrial wastes.
Waiting for death: A widow in Varanasi, one of many who lead a
pitiable existence
Countless residents of Varanasi share the view that the city has
become a hideout for criminals. Police records show that in the last
three years, 211 persons were done to death and 58 women raped.
According to S.S. Solanki, a local crime reporter, Varanasi has 163
hardcore criminals carrying rewards on their heads.
In the last ten years, over two dozen foreign tourists have become
victims of crime. On July 15, 2001, a German woman was raped by two
persons including the owner of the guest house she was staying in.
The police are yet to crack the cases involving the mysterious deaths
of four foreigners in the last two years.
The most heinous crime on a foreigner was the gang rape and murder of
one Diana of Switzerland in 1998. Six months later, the police
arrested the killers and recovered her decomposed body.
Most cases of rape go unreported or are even suppressed by higher
officials to save the city's reputation. Says a police officer:
"Three months ago, the head priest of a mutt raped a tourist. But the
victim was persuaded to withdraw her complaint as the priest was very
powerful."
A few sociologists may argue that the sordid mixture of crime and
decay has been there in the west as well. Money has been the moving
force in any established religion and a cause of conflict; the
history of the Christian church has always been one of revolt when
matters temporal supplanted the spiritual. The history of holy places
of other religions, too, has not been without aberrations. But this
is no argument to justify the festering sores of holy India.
Blame it on kalyug, the age where dharma-the moral order of the
world-is precariously balanced between imperfection and perfection,
darkness and light. Or just maya.
With Vijaya Pushkarna/Pehowa, Deepak Tiwari/Amarkantak, Dnyanesh
Jathar/Pandharpur &
Lalita Iyer/Hyderabad
_____
#8.
Hindutva at Work:
Outlook India, India - 17 Jan 2003
Himachal VHP asks parties to include its demands in manifestos
http://www.outlookindia.com/pti_news.asp?id=112490
Sify, India - 17 Jan 2003
Stand up for self, VHP to US Hindus
http://news.sify.com/cgi-bin/sifynews/news/content/news_fullstory_v2.jsp?article_oid=12532382&category_oid=-20612&page_no=1
Pakistan News Service, Pakistan - 12 Jan 2003
Hindu Extremists Use British Indians Charity
http://www.paknews.com/flash.php?id=5&date1=2003-01-13
______
#9.
Financial Times
January 15 2003
Low caste leader's high-cost party
By Edward Luce
Residents of Lucknow, capital of Uttar Pradesh, India's largest
state with 170m people, on Wednesday played host to one of the most
brazen displays of personality cult India has seen.
Mayawati, chief minister of Uttar Pradesh, and leader of a party that
represents India's Dalit, or untouchable, caste, celebrated her 47th
birthday in a style redolent of Imelda Marcos, widow of the former
dictator of the Philippines.
Ms Mayawati, who, like many of her caste, has no second name, invited
25,000 guests to enjoy, at the state government's expense, a lavish
reception against the backdrop of a specially designed Bollywood film
set.
More than 200,000 laddoos - north Indian sweets - were baked as well
as a 50kg birthday cake. An exhibition of the life and times of Ms
Mayawati was on display, all at the taxpayers' expense. Estimates of
the cost ranged from $2m to $5m - in a state with a per capita income
of less than $300 compared with the national average of $500.
India's estimated 200m untouchables - about a fifth of the population
- have become increasingly assertive over the past decade in spite of
continued widespread discrimination against them, especially in rural
India. Untouchable and lower caste parties, led by Ms Mayawati and
others, have come to power in several of the country's populous
states.
The performance of untouchables in office has, however, been mixed.
Udit Raj, an untouchable leader who opposes Ms Mayawati, says:
"Mayawati has taken personality politics to an obscene level. She is
supposed to represent the poorest and most downtrodden in society but
she is dining openly at their expense."
Opponents of Ms Mayawati's capricious leadership style on
Wednesday contrasted her celebrations with the fate of many of the
state's poorest villagers who are suffering from one of north India's
coldest snaps in years. Almost 400 have died from hypothermia in the
past three days.
Since taking power in March in an unlikely coalition with India's
ruling Hindu nationalist BJP, dominated by upper caste Brahmins, Ms
Mayawati has ignored the conventional objectives of government. Her
administration has focused on symbolic gestures such as pouring state
funds into the creation of an urban park dedicated to B.R. Ambedkar,
post-colonial Dalit leader.
She has acquired notoriety for frequently transferring mostly upper
caste civil servants from post to post for no discernible reason.
Last year the World Bank complained to her that this severely
undermined the development projects it was funding.
Yogendra Yadav, a political scientist, says: "Mayawati appears to
delight in the politics of the whimsical at the expense of more
serious development goals. The fact she is in coalition with the
upper caste BJP - traditional enemies of the Dalits - shows there is
really no ideology left at all."
On a visit to Bilamburpurawa, a village 30km north of Lucknow, Mr Raj
yesterday steered well clear of the chief minister's birthday bash.
The village, in which five Dalits were recently attacked by upper
caste neighbours, who threw acid into their eyes, is typical of the
impoverished Hindi belt in northern India.
The assailants believed the five men, owing to their untouchable
status, would have polluted the water of a pond in which they had
been fishing. The culprits were released after six months in
detention. The victims are hideously scarred. Mr Raj asks: "How can
you live with Hinduism when it defines some people as sub- human? He
left his job as a senior tax official in New Delhi to convert Dalits
to Buddhism. "We have no choice but convert if we want to regain our
dignity."
Mr Raj says he has converted 400,000 Dalits to Buddhism, most notably
in November 2001 when 150,000 people took part in a mass conversion
rally in New Delhi. On Wednesday Mr Raj won over 50 more people in a
ceremony staged just outside the state's legislative assembly.
"Anything is better than Hinduism - even Islam," he says. "Islam at
least accepts in theory that all people are equal before God."
Leaders of the western state of Gujarat, where the BJP last month won
a landslide election victory following India's worst Hindu-Muslim
riots in a decade, have taken note of Mr Raj's "anti-Hindu" activism.
Narendra Modi, controversial chief minister of Gujarat, who allegedly
helped orchestrate the anti-Muslim riots in February, plans to enact
an anti-conversion bill.
Mr Modi's hardline election campaign was aided by Ms Mayawati's support.
Mr Raj says: "Ms Mayawati has completely sold out to the forces of
Hindu nationalism. How can you complain about being a Dalit when you
are in alliance with Brahmin chauvinists?"
_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/
SACW is an informal, independent & non-profit citizens wire service run by
South Asia Citizens Web (www.mnet.fr/aiindex) since 1996.
To subscribe send a blank message to:
<act-subscribe@yahoogroups.com> / To unsubscribe send a blank
message to: <act-unsubscribe@yahoogroups.com>
________________________________________
DISCLAIMER: Opinions expressed in materials carried in the posts do not
necessarily reflect the views of SACW compilers.
\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//\\|//|//\\|//|//\\|//|//\\|//|
--